Du solltest: Giving Advice
A2.13
Giving advice in German is all about finding the right tone. While learners often default to du musst (you must), this can sound like a harsh command to native speakers. In this lesson, you will unlock friendly, polite advice using du solltest (you should), suggest alternatives with es wäre besser, put yourself in their shoes with an deiner Stelle, and master helpful offers using soll ich.
Step 1
The Power of "Sollte" (Friendly Advice)
Instead of commanding someone with "müssen", use the subjunctive form of "sollen" to make recommendations soft and polite.
You should go to the doctor. → Du solltest zum Arzt gehen.
One should drink more water. → Man sollte mehr Wasser trinken.
We should go home. → Wir sollten nach Hause gehen.
Grammar Rule sollte behaves like a modal verb. The main verb (e.g., gehen, trinken) is placed at the very end of the sentence in its infinitive form.
Step 2
"An deiner Stelle" (In your shoes)
To give highly empathetic advice, use the conditional frame "An deiner Stelle würde ich..." (In your place, I would...).
In your place, I would sleep. → An deiner Stelle würde ich schlafen.
In your place, I would definitely do that. → An deiner Stelle würde ich das auf jeden Fall tun.
In your place, I'd better not do that. → An deiner Stelle würde ich das besser nicht tun.
Idiom Focus auf jeden Fall = definitely / in any case
besser nicht = better not
Step 3
Pattern Unlock: Advice Frames
Let's compare the three main structures for recommending actions.
Structure | German Pattern | English Meaning
Direct Soft Advice | du solltest + ... + infinitive | You should...
Hypothetical Advice | an deiner Stelle + würde ich + ... + infinitive | In your place, I would...
Impersonal Suggestion | es wäre besser, ... zu + infinitive | It would be better to...
The "zu" Clause When using es wäre besser, the following verb needs zu right before the infinitive:
Es wäre besser zu warten. (It would be better to wait.)
Step 4
Offering Help & Suggestions
Germans constantly use the present tense of "sollen" to offer help or suggest group decisions.
Should I help you? → Soll ich dir helfen?
Should we take a taxi? → Sollen wir ein Taxi nehmen?
Should we definitely go? → Sollen wir auf jeden Fall gehen?
Pronunciation Tip Note the difference between the present tense soll / sollen (for offers/suggestions) and the subjunctive sollte / sollten (for advice).
Step 5
Mini Conversation
Listen to how these patterns flow in a natural dialogue between friends.
A Ich habe Kopfschmerzen. Was soll ich tun? I have a headache. What should I do?
B Du solltest nach Hause gehen. Es wäre besser, zu schlafen. You should go home. It would be better to sleep.
A Sollen wir ein Taxi nehmen? Should we take a taxi?
B Ja, auf jeden Fall. An deiner Stelle würde ich jetzt nicht laufen. Yes, definitely. In your shoes, I wouldn't walk right now.
Step 6
Echo & Try It
Translate the English prompts into German to test your recall.
1. You should stay here. → ________ hier bleiben. Use "du solltest"
2. In your place, I wouldn't do that. → ________ würde ich das nicht tun. Use "an deiner Stelle"
3. Should we take a taxi? → ________ ein ________ nehmen? Use "sollen wir" and "Taxi"
4. It would be better to wait. → ________ zu warten. Use "es wäre besser"
Reference
Vocabulary
Key terms and structures covered in this lesson.
German | English | Notes
du solltest | you should | Subjunctive form of sollen; friendly advice.
man sollte | one should | General advice / rules.
wir sollten | we should | Suggestions for a group.
an deiner Stelle | in your shoes / place | Followed by würde ich...
soll ich | should I / shall I | Used to offer help: Soll ich helfen?
sollen wir | should we / shall we | Used to propose an action: Sollen wir gehen?
es wäre besser | it would be better | Triggers a infinitive clause with zu.
das Taxi | the taxi | Neuter noun: ein Taxi nehmen.
auf jeden Fall | definitely / in any case | Idiomatic booster phrase.
besser nicht | better not | Used for negative advice: Lieber besser nicht.
Wrap-up
You have successfully moved past commanding people with müssen. By using du solltest, an deiner Stelle, and es wäre besser, your advice now sounds polite, natural, and helpful. Additionally, you can now proactively offer assistance or guide group plans using soll ich / sollen wir.