Er fragte, ob...; sie sagte, ich solle warten: Questions and Commands

B2.03

When summarizing meetings, retelling stories, or writing formal reports in German, you need to report more than just simple facts. This lesson unlocks how to report questions and commands / requests in a formal written style. You will master the use of Konjunktiv I and Konjunktiv II combined with shifting reporting structures like er fragte, ob and ich solle.

Step 1

What You'll Learn

The concrete skills that bridge the gap from colloquial speech to formal German writing.

Your Goals 1. Report questions using ob (if/whether) or question words with verb-final word order.

2. Report commands using the modal verb sollen in Konjunktiv I (ich solle, er solle).

3. Report polite requests using the Konjunktiv form möchten / mögen (sie möge).

4. Avoid the classic word-order trap of keeping direct question word order inside your indirect reports.

Step 2

Pattern Unlock: Reporting Questions

When reporting a question, keep the question word (or use "ob" for yes/no questions) and push the conjugated verb to the very end.

Direct: "Do you have time?" → „Hast du Zeit?“

Reported: He asked if I had time. → Er fragte, ob ich Zeit hätte.

Direct: "When does the train arrive?" → „Wann kommt der Zug an?“

Reported: She wanted to know when the train arrived. → Sie wollte wissen, wann der Zug ankomme.

Grammar Logic Use Konjunktiv I (ankomme) as the standard formal choice. If the Konjunktiv I form is identical to the normal present tense (indicative), shift to Konjunktiv II (hätte) to keep the reported speech distinct.

Step 3

Reporting Commands: "Sollen" in Action

Direct commands are converted into indirect speech using the Konjunktiv I form of sollen.

Direct: "Wait!" → „Warten Sie!“

Reported: She said I should wait. → Sie sagte, ich solle warten.

Direct: "He must do his homework." → „Er muss seine Hausaufgaben machen.“

Reported: She said he should do his homework. → Sie sagte, er solle seine Hausaufgaben machen.

Command Rule An imperative or a strong demand (die Aufforderung) becomes solle / sollen in reported speech. This removes the harsh tone of the imperative while preserving the obligation.

Step 4

Polite Requests: "Mögen" and "Möchten"

When reporting a polite request (die Bitte), use the Konjunktiv I of mögen (möge) or the subjunctive möchten.

Direct: "Please come in." → „Kommen Sie bitte herein!“

Reported: They asked us to wait outside. → Man bat uns, wir möchten draußen warten.

Reported: He requested that she join the meeting. → Er bat darum, sie möge am Treffen teilnehmen.

Reporting Verbs Use bitten (to request/ask) or auffordern (to summon/demand) to frame the reported command or request.

Step 5

Konjunktiv I Conjugation: Sollen & Mögen

These are the precise formal forms you need for reported commands and requests.

Pronoun | sollen (Konjunktiv I) | mögen (Konjunktiv I)

ich | ich solle | ich möge

du | du sollest | du mögest

er / sie / es | er solle | sie möge

wir | wir sollen (use KII: sollten) | wir mögen (use KII: möchten)

ihr | ihr sollet | ihr möget

sie / Sie | sie sollen (use KII: sollten) | sie mögen (use KII: möchten)

Step 6

The Classic Word-Order Trap

Do not preserve the original question word order inside indirect speech. The verb must go to the end!

Incorrect Order → ❌ Er fragte, wann kommt der Zug an.

Correct Order → ✅ Er fragte, wann der Zug ankomme.

Word Order Rule All reported questions and commands introduced by a subordinating conjunction (ob), a question word (wann, wer, wie), or a relative pronoun require verb-final subordinate clause structure.

Step 7

Echo & Try It

Complete the reported statements with the correct Konjunktiv form.

1. Der Arzt sagte, ich ________ mich ausruhen. (sollen - Konjunktiv I for "ich")

2. Sie wollte wissen, ob er morgen Zeit ________. (haben - Konjunktiv II for "er", since KI "habe" is identical to direct speech context)

3. Man bat uns, wir ________ draußen warten. (möchten - polite request plural)

Step 8

Mini Conversation

See how direct dialogue shifts into formal reported speech.

Direct Dialogue Polizist: „Bitte warten Sie hier. Wann kommt Ihr Kollege?“ Police Officer: "Please wait here. When is your colleague coming?"

Reported Summary Der Polizist forderte uns auf, wir möchten hier warten, und sich erkundigte, wann unser Kollege ankomme. The police officer requested us to wait here and inquired when our colleague would arrive.

Reference

Vocabulary

Key verbs and terms for reporting questions and commands.

German | English | Notes

er fragte | he asked | Past tense of fragen, introduces reported questions.

ob | if / whether | Introduces reported yes/no questions with verb at the end.

sie wollte wissen | she wanted to know | Frame for reported questions.

ich solle | I should (reported command) | Konjunktiv I of sollen.

er solle | he should (reported command) | Konjunktiv I of sollen.

sie möge | she should / may (polite request) | Konjunktiv I of mögen.

man bat uns | we were requested / they asked us | Passive-like active frame with bitten.

bitten | to ask / request | Strongly associated with polite requests.

auffordern | to summon / demand / call upon | Introduces commands (die Aufforderung).

die Aufforderung | the demand / summons / command | Noun form of auffordern.

die Bitte | the request / plea | Noun form of bitten.

sich erkundigen | to inquire / ask about | Reflexive verb used for formal reported questions.

Wrap-up

You can now formally report any question or instruction in German. Remember to use ob or the question word for questions, and shift commands into Konjunktiv I forms of sollen (solle) or mögen (möge). Keep your verbs pushed to the end of the subordinate clauses to maintain flawless German syntax.