Comi, Abri: -ER and -IR in the Past (and Você Já Comeu?)

A2.03

You already know how to talk about the past with -AR verbs like falar (falei, falou).

Now, you will master the past tense for the other two verb families: -ER and -IR. Along the way, you will learn to sidestep a massive English-to-Portuguese translation trap when asking "Have you eaten?".

Step 1

What You'll Learn

Set your targets for this past-tense milestone.

Goals

Conjugate regular -ER and -IR verbs in the simple past for all main pronoun groups.

Avoid the "ar-verb contamination" trap (saying "comou" instead of comeu).

Express completed past actions with "already" using já.

Master the phrase agora há pouco to mean "a moment ago."

Step 2

Pattern Unlock: -ER Past Conjugation

Let's look at how -ER verbs behave in the past. We will use comer (to eat) and beber (to drink) as our models.

Pronoun | Ending | Comer (to eat) | Beber (to drink)

Eu (I) | -i | comi | bebi

Você / Ele / Ela (You/He/She) | -eu | comeu | bebeu

Vocês / Eles / Elas (You all/They) | -eram | comeram | beberam

The "Comou" Trap English speakers often accidentally apply the -AR past ending (-ou) to -ER verbs.

✖ Ele comou

✅ Ele comeu (He ate)

Keep the families separate: -AR verbs use -ou, but -ER verbs use -eu!

Step 3

Pattern Unlock: -IR Past Conjugation

-IR verbs share almost identical endings with -ER verbs in the past, making them highly predictable.

Pronoun | Ending | Abrir (to open) | Dormir (to sleep)

Eu (I) | -i | abri | dormi

Você / Ele / Ela (You/He/She) | -iu | abriu | dormiu

Vocês / Eles / Elas (You all/They) | -iram | abriram | dormiram

More -IR Verbs This exact same pattern applies to assistir (to watch) and decidir (to decide):

· assisti (I watched) / assistiu (he/she/you watched) / assistiram (they watched)

· decidi (I decided) / decidiu (he/she/you decided) / decidiram (they decided)

Step 4

The Big English Perfect-Tense Trap

How do you ask "Have you eaten?" or "Have you watched the game?" in Portuguese?

The Rule Do NOT translate "Have you eaten?" literally as "Você tem comido?".

In Portuguese, Você tem comido? actually means "Have you been eating lately?" (as an ongoing habit over the last few days/weeks).

To ask if someone has eaten or completed an action recently, use the Simple Past + já (already):

👉 Você já comeu? (Have you eaten? / Did you already eat?)

Have you eaten? (Did you eat yet?) → Você já comeu?

Have you been eating well lately? → Você tem comido bem?

Did they already open the door? → Eles já abriram a porta?

Step 5

"A Moment Ago": Agora Há Pouco

When answering questions about the very recent past, use this essential time marker.

Time Marker agora há pouco = a moment ago / just now

I ate a moment ago. → Comi agora há pouco.

He slept a moment ago. → Ele dormiu agora há pouco.

I opened it a moment ago. → Eu abri agora há pouco.

Step 6

Mini Conversation

Listen to how these past-tense conjugations and the "já" pattern flow in a real conversation.

A Você já comeu? Have you eaten?

B Sim, comi agora há pouco. E você? Yes, I ate a moment ago. And you?

A Eu não comi, mas bebi um suco. Vocês assistiram ao jogo? I didn't eat, but I drank a juice. Did you guys watch the game?

B Eu não assisti. Decidi dormir cedo, mas eles comeram pizza e assistiram. I didn't watch it. I decided to sleep early, but they ate pizza and watched it.

Step 7

Echo & Try It

Fill in the blanks with the correct past tense conjugations.

1. Have you eaten? Você já ________? (comer)

2. They opened the window a moment ago. Eles ________ a janela agora há pouco. (abrir)

3. I watched the game. Eu ________ ao jogo. (assistir)

4. She drank the water. Ela ________ a água. (beber)

Answer Key 1. comeu

2. abriram

3. assisti

4. bebeu

Reference

Vocabulary

Key terms covered in this lesson. Tap any Portuguese word to hear it.

Portuguese / English

bebeu he/she/you drank

dormiu he/she/you slept

comeram they/you all ate

abri I opened

abriu he/she/you opened

abriram they/you all opened

assisti I watched

assistiu he/she/you watched

decidi I decided

decidiu he/she/you decided

agora há pouco a moment ago / just now

o jogo the game / match

você já comeu? have you eaten?

Wrap-up

You can now conjugate -ER and -IR verbs smoothly in the past tense. Remember:

-ER past: -i, -eu, -eram

-IR past: -i, -iu, -iram

And most importantly, never translate "Have you eaten?" literally. Always use the simple past with já: Você já comeu?.